Really Personal Podcast

Why Good People Get Tired of Being Good People

Posted by:

Mary Ann Addis

I'm
Mary Ann

A music educator who just needed a larger classroom. Let's create, share, connect, and inspire! 

hey y'all

Get My Self-care guide

Gimme that

Easy & delicious recipes for your plates & cocktail glasses!

TOp categories

Not shying away from the deep stuff!

Say YES to new adventures! All aboard!

Cheeky way to be the master of your domain!

Be you, Do you, Love you, For you!

@mary.ann.life

Compassion is incomplete if it doesn’t include yourself.

-Dr. Kristin Neff

 

If you’ve ever wondered why being kind, thoughtful, and dependable can leave you feeling exhausted, you’re not alone. So many of us carry the unspoken role of the “good one”—the friend who always listens, the coworker who picks up the slack, the family member who keeps the peace.

But here’s the truth: being good shouldn’t mean being depleted.

This blog post is adapted from Episode 65 of The Really Personal Podcast, where I dig into why good people are burning out—and how to stay kind without losing yourself in the process.

 

 

The Cost of Caring

Being the “good one” is exhausting when the world keeps asking for more than you can give. Maybe you’re:

  • The friend everyone vents to—but who rarely gets asked how you’re doing.
  • The coworker who takes on the “small” tasks that add up to burnout.
  • The family member who “just handles things,” like it’s your job to keep the peace.

Psychologists call the weight of this compassion fatigue—a kind of emotional burnout that happens when you give and give without boundaries, rest, or reciprocity.
It shows up as:

  • Irritability or snapping at things that usually wouldn’t bother you
  • Feeling used, but struggling to say no
  • Guilt, even when you finally do rest

Compassion fatigue isn’t weakness. It’s your body’s way of saying: “I have limits too.” And in a world full of constant noise—economic stress, online drama, family dynamics—it’s no wonder so many of us feel tapped out.

 

The Fatigue of Always Understanding

Here’s where things get tricky: many of us were taught that being “good” means being endlessly understanding. But here’s the reality: understanding should be a bridge, not a trap. Some people don’t meet you halfway. They expect you to carry their pain, but when it comes time to hold yours? Silence.
That’s when compassion turns into self-erasure.

And boundaries don’t always require a dramatic confrontation. Sometimes it’s as simple as:

  • Letting the phone go to voicemail.
  • Texting: “I can’t talk right now, but I’ll check in tomorrow.”
  • Saying: “I hear you. I care. I just don’t have the capacity for this right now.”

Small actions like this protect your energy while still keeping kindness intact. Remember:

  • Being gracious doesn’t mean being gullible.
  • Being kind doesn’t mean being a doormat.
  • Being open-minded doesn’t mean letting people trash your values while you keep smiling.

As researcher Kristin Neff puts it: “Compassion is incomplete if it doesn’t include yourself.”

 

 

Kindness Without Boundaries = Burnout

Here’s the uncomfortable truth: kindness without boundaries isn’t kindness—it’s martyrdom. And martyrdom might win you applause, but it also wins you burnout, resentment, and invisibility. Think about it:

  • At work, you become the “reliable one” who never says no.
  • In your family, you’re the peacemaker, smoothing over every conflict.
  • In friendships or relationships, you’re the steady listener—but who’s listening to you?

That’s not love. That’s emotional janitorial work. Boundaries aren’t selfish. They’re how you protect your peace. A loving “no” is always more valuable than a resentful “yes.”

 

 

How to Stay Good Without Burning Out

So how do we stay good without losing ourselves?

Here are 8 reminders to keep your kindness intact and sustainable:

  1. Redefine “good.”
    Good doesn’t mean agreeable. It can mean direct, honest, and boundaried.
  2. Check your body before you say yes.
    If your gut flips or your chest tightens, that’s data. Pause before you agree.
  3. Let “no” be holy.
    Every “no” to what drains you is a “yes” to what sustains you.
  4. Follow resentment like a compass.
    Resentment isn’t weakness—it’s a signal that a boundary is missing.
  5. Practice micro-boundaries.
    Small phrases work wonders: “I can’t talk tonight, but I care.”
    Boundaries don’t have to be walls—they can be velvet ropes.
  6. Stop being everyone’s emotional airbag.
    You are not a crash-test dummy for other people’s meltdowns.
  7. Rest without earning it.
    Rest is not a reward. It’s a right.
  8. Choose people who don’t need you to bleed to prove you love them.
    The right people honor your no as much as your yes.

This isn’t about being less kind—it’s about being less depleted.

 

 

Life Journals and Planners | Mary Ann Life Blog

Final Reflections

Good people get tired.
Not because they’ve lost their goodness, but because they’ve been running on empty.

Your kindness is not the problem.
The problem is when kindness turns into self-abandonment.

So remember this:

  • You can still be kind and say no.
  • You can still be loving and walk away.
  • You can still be a good person without being a damn doormat.

Because goodness that costs you your joy, your health, or your identity? That’s not goodness. That’s erasure.

Take care of you. Protect your peace. The world doesn’t just need good people. It needs well-rested, clear-eyed, soft-hearted, strong-backed people.

And that, my friend—that’s you.

 

 

Book Recommendation

The Gifts of Imperfection: 10th Anniversary Edition: Features a new foreword and brand-new tools

The Mountain Is You

+ show Comments

- Hide Comments

add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

GET SHOPPING

Journals & Planners

Jump-start your writing and meditation practice along with the perfect way to approach each day with intentions and gratitude.

browse MA shop →

life

Hey, it's totally cool to be a jack-of-all-trades in this life! I'm on a mission to create, share, connect, and motivate others to live their most fantastic lives. And trust me, the party's just getting started!

&

Get to know me!

listen

Bingeworthy Shows

Really Personal

Let's Get Real, y'all!

If you're looking to create positive and lasting change in your life, then you'll want to join us on the Really Personal Podcast. Join us on our journey as we share stories of personal growth, self-care and            lessons.

Online Dating Isn’t That Horrible, Right?

THERE’S MORE BENEATH THE SURFACE OF THE AVOIDANT ATTACHMENT STYLE THAN YOU THINK

You Need to Feel to Heal

Phrase Replacements in Relationships: what works, and what works better

To Live a Creative Life, We Must Choose Curiosity Rather Than Fear

things just got real, y'all

life

Podcast

Listen on:

Let's get real, y'all!

The go-to podcast where sugar coatin' and beatin' around the bush isn't allowed!

Podcast

Listen on:

Apple

Amazon

Pandora

Spotify

iHeart

Steal this!

e-book with 10 glorious recipes

It may not be a hardcover cookbook to collect dust on your kitchen shelf, but it's easily accessible on any screen!